topic one: language and power
I am responding to the first topic on the relationship between power and language. I have a different perspective on this issue than I think Delpit does. I work with toddlers with Autism so I see the power of language in its very basic form. Our kids are often without any means to communicate. Our first goal is simply to teach a child to express him/her self. If gestures and unintelligible jargon is the only result then we are successful. Teaching a child to communicate effectively should be the most important aspect of being a teacher. I believe the community should have a say in what kind of language is central to that child’s future, but the child needs to have the last word. Regardless of what we tell children is the “right” language, children will succeed if they are confident.
Jessye Saemenes
1 Comments:
I agree that children will succeed if they are confident, but how can the children have the last word in language? They develop their own language as they grow, adding slang and such to a basic form, but then they too become adults. How else can children cope in society if they don't 'conform' and learn the language of the powerful community? If a child can't communicate with his society, then who is to blame but the society for not teaching him what he needed to know?
Post a Comment
<< Home